Updated on 01/04/26 by Mananjay MahatoShare on WhatsApp

Core Comparison Table

Feature Soldering (Soft) Brazing (Hard) Welding
Temperature Below 450°C (842°F) Above 450°C (842°F) Above Melting Point of Base Metal
Base Metal Does not melt Does not melt Melts and fuses
Joint Strength Low (not for pressure) High (Standard for RAC) Highest
Bonding Type Surface Adhesion Capillary Action + Alloying Fusion
RAC Use Case Electrical/PCBs Copper piping/Coils Structural frames/Chassis

2. Soldering in RAC

Primarily used for electrical connections and low-pressure water lines.

  • Filler Metal (Solder): Alloy of Tin (Sn) and Lead (Pb). Common ratio is 60:40.

  • Flux: Typically Rosin-based (for electronics) or Zinc Chloride (for plumbing). It prevents oxidation during heating.

  • Technique: Uses a soldering iron or a small butane torch.

  • Fact for Exams: “Tinning” is the process of coating the soldering iron tip with a thin layer of solder to improve heat transfer.


3. Brazing: The Standard for RAC

90% of joints in a refrigeration circuit (compressor to condenser, evaporator to capillary) are brazed.

  • Capillary Action: The ability of the molten filler to flow into narrow gaps regardless of gravity.

  • Filler Materials:

    • Silver Brazing Alloy (Silver Solder): Contains 5% to 45% Silver. High strength, used for joining copper to steel/brass.

    • Phos-Copper: (Copper + Phosphorus). Used for Copper-to-Copper joints.

  • Self-Fluxing: Phos-copper alloys are self-fluxing on copper. The phosphorus removes the copper oxide.

  • Purging: While brazing, Dry Nitrogen must be bled through the pipe at low pressure (1-2 PSI) to prevent “Cupric Oxide” (black soot) from forming inside the pipe, which could clog the expansion valve.


4. Gas Welding (Oxy-Acetylene)

Standard heat source for brazing and light welding in RAC.

  • The Equipment:

    • Oxygen Cylinder: Painted Black. (High pressure, ~2000 PSI).

    • Acetylene Cylinder: Painted Maroon/Red. (Dissolved in Acetone, ~250 PSI).

  • Flame Types:

    • Neutral Flame: Equal Oxygen/Acetylene. Used for most welding.

    • Oxidizing Flame: Excess Oxygen. Used for welding brass/bronze.

    • Carburizing (Reducing) Flame: Excess Acetylene. Used for brazing and hard-facing.


5. Critical Safety & Knowledge (Exams Focus)

  • Flashback Arrestor: A safety device fitted to the regulator/torch to stop a flame from traveling back into the cylinders.

  • Cleaning: Joints must be mechanically cleaned (sandpaper/emery cloth) and chemically cleaned (flux) to ensure a proper bond.

  • Direction of Heat: Always heat the thicker pipe or the female part of the joint first; the filler metal always flows toward the heat.

  • Pressure Testing: After brazing, the system is tested with Nitrogen at high pressure to check for leaks using soap solution or electronic detectors.

Key Fact: In RAC, Silver Brazing is often incorrectly called “Silver Soldering,” but technically, since it happens above 450°C, it is always a Brazing process.

4.Welding Soldering Brazing